Skip to content
Greenville Plumbing Help

Tank and tankless, gas and electric

Water heater repair and replacement in Greenville, SC

A water heater is the biggest plumbing appliance in most houses, and the decision between repairing it and replacing it is where the money goes. Know what you have before you call.

First, look at the label

The sticker on the side of the tank gives the fuel, the size in gallons and a serial number. Most makers code the year of manufacture into that serial number, and the plumber can read it for you. Have a photo of the label ready when you call.

Note whether there is a gas pipe with a shut-off valve going into the bottom, or a thick electrical cable going into the top. Gas and electric heaters fail in different ways.

Illustration: a tank water heater cut open, showing the cold inlet tube reaching the bottom, hot water leaving the top, the anode rod, the relief valve and its pipe, the drain valve and sediment on the floor of the tank.
Cold water enters at the top and travels down a tube to the bottom of the tank. Heated water rises and leaves from the top. The rod down the middle protects the steel lining, and the valve on the side opens if pressure or temperature climbs too high.

What the symptom usually points to

Gas heater

  • No hot water at all: the pilot or burner is not lighting. Often a part, not a tank.
  • Hot water runs out fast: sediment has built up in the bottom, or the dip tube has broken.
  • Rumbling or popping: water trapped under sediment boiling against the hot floor of the tank.
  • A smell of gas near the heater: leave and call the gas company, not a plumber. See below.

Electric heater

  • Lukewarm water: one of the two heating elements or its thermostat has failed.
  • No hot water and a tripped breaker: an element shorted out. Leave the breaker off.
  • Hot water for one shower and no more: the lower element is usually the one gone.
  • Water pooling under the tank: see the next section, whatever the fuel.

Water under the tank

Find where it comes from before you decide anything. Drips from a pipe joint on top, from the drain valve near the bottom or from the relief valve pipe can be fixed. Water seeping from the tank body itself, or rust streaks from under the jacket, mean the lining has failed and the tank has to be replaced.

To stop the flow, close the cold water valve on the pipe going into the top of the heater. Turn the gas control to off or switch the breaker off. Do not open the relief valve to test it on an old tank that is already leaking; it may not close again.

Repair or replace?

No one can make this call for you over the phone, but these are the facts a plumber will weigh.

Repair usually makes sense when

  • the tank itself is dry and only a part has failed
  • the heater is well short of the age printed in its warranty
  • the problem is a thermostat, element, igniter, gas valve or dip tube

Replacement usually makes sense when

  • the tank body leaks or is rusting through
  • it is past its warranty period and a major part has failed
  • you are short of hot water every day and want a larger or different unit

Tank or tankless?

A tankless heater warms water only as it flows, so it never runs out, but it delivers a limited flow at once. Two showers and a dishwasher together may be more than one unit can keep hot. Ask the plumber to size it for the fixtures you run at the same time, not for the size of the house.

Switching to gas tankless often means a larger gas line and a new vent through the wall or roof. Switching to electric tankless can mean a much larger electrical supply. Both change the job from a swap into a small project, and both should be priced as such.

A like-for-like tank in the same spot is the simplest replacement. Moving the heater, changing fuel or going tankless adds work for gas, venting or wiring trades.

What a replacement day looks like

  1. Drain and disconnect

    The old tank is drained through a hose, which takes a while if the bottom is full of sediment. Water and gas or power are shut off and the connections cut.

  2. Set the new heater

    In a closet or attic, the new tank sits in a drain pan where code calls for one. The relief valve gets a full-size pipe running to a safe place.

  3. Connect and test

    Water first, then fuel. Gas joints are leak-tested. The tank is filled completely before an electric heater is switched on, or the elements burn out.

  4. Permit and inspection

    Inside the City of Greenville a replacement is plumbing work that needs a permit. The permits guide explains the rule, including what happens when the swap cannot wait.

Ask before you agree

  • Is the price in writing, and does it include taking the old tank away?
  • Who pulls the permit, and is the inspection part of the job?
  • Will the new heater need a drain pan, an expansion tank or a new relief pipe here?
  • If I am going tankless, what gas, vent or electrical work comes with it?
  • What does the manufacturer's warranty cover, and is labor covered separately?

Water heater questions

Does Greenville's soft water mean less sediment?

Greenville Water's own reports class its water as soft, so mineral scale is less of a problem than in many places. Tanks still collect sediment and rust flakes over the years, which is why draining a little from the bottom valve now and then is worth asking about.

Can the plumber come back and finish the permit later?

City rules let emergency replacements go ahead with the permit application filed by the next working business day. Ask the plumber to confirm in writing that they will file it.

Is a water heater in the attic a problem?

It works, but a leak there does more damage. Ask whether the drain pan has a pipe running out of the house, and whether a leak sensor or automatic shut-off valve is worth adding.

Cold shower this morning?

Have the label photo and the fuel type ready. Say whether water is on the floor. The plumbing company on the phone will tell you whether they handle your heater and when they can look at it.

Reach a Greenville-area plumbing firm

Homeowners and renters with trouble in their own pipes, drains, fixtures or tank.

Call (864) 555-0136

Recording may be switched on. Money changing hands for referrals: disclosure. Your details: privacy.

Call (864) 555-0136